Sonic the Hedgehog’s Fantastic Redesign Fails to Solve Movie’s Critical Flaws

0 40


  • Sonic the Hedgehog looks so much better after the redesign.
  • But while the movie might not suck, that doesn’t mean it should win any awards.
  • Jim Carrey is still a weird choice for Dr. Robotnik. And why in the world is this movie live-action?

Sonic the Hedgehog’s fate looks immensely brighter following the release of a new trailer for the embattled film.

This trailer for Sonic the Hedgehog shows off the major redesign to the character following fan backlash to the original. It looks like everything fans had an issue with has been cleared up. No longer does the blue blur look like an uncanny valley monstrosity haunting the nightmares of children.

That’s excellent news for Sonic the Hedgehog fans, but is it enough to save the film? I’m not so sure. The movie definitely still has some hiccups that could keep it from being a success.

Why Isn’t Sonic the Hedgehog Just a CGI Movie?

The first of these is its mix of live-action and CGI.

I really don’t understand going this route. The whole controversy could have been avoided if Paramount Pictures just started off with a complete CGI film. It’s already what Nintendo is planning with Mario.

Plus, there would never have been an ugly Sonic in the first place. Now, we have a much more cartoonish Sonic, albeit one prancing around the real world.

It’s better than before, but it still feels off.

I would never guess this is Dr. Robotnik if I didn’t already know. | Source: Paramount/YouTube

Jim Carrey Is Great, But He’s No Dr. Robotnik

Another problem the Sonic the Hedgehog movie has is Dr. Robotnik.

Listen, I love Jim Carrey as much as the next guy, but he’s far from the perfect fit for this role. Not that it matters, because the film doesn’t even fully embrace the character.

Fans have seen a brief glimpse of him looking more like the original Dr. Robotnik, but that just appears to be a nod to the games the film is based on.

Before anyone asks, Kevin James would be a much better Dr. Robotnik.

Putting Sonic on Earth still doesn’t make a lot of sense. | Source: Twitter

Why Can’t Paramount Just Keep Sonic in His Own World?

My next concern with the Sonic the Hedgehog movie has to do with the setting.

Was anyone really asking for a film that pulls Sonic from his own world and drops him in ours? It just seems like such a strange choice.

The creators could have still had their human characters and put the movie in the Sonic Adventure setting, but this isn’t the case.

Take a Look at the Trailer to See the New Sonic

Let’s not forget the biggest mistake with the Sonic the Hedgehog film. The one that is killing it before it ever hits theaters. A travesty so bad that no redesign of Sonic can fix it.

Where is Jaleel White?

Alright. That last point was a joke, but I’m still skeptical about the Sonic the Hedgehog film. Optimistically so, but still skeptical.

This article was edited by Josiah Wilmoth.

Last modified: November 12, 2019 16:03 UTC



You might also like

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share this post with your friends!

WhatsApp chat